We are working on a new Futurelab website. This means our current one may have hiccups. We apologize for any poor experience or layout.
by Jonathan Salem Baskin on 5 March, 2012 - 23:01
The U.S. auto industry is heading for a banner year...so much so that there’s a question whether manufacturers will be able to keep up with demand, especially for trucks. Tens of thousands of people are being put back to work at auto plants and parts suppliers, not to mention the additional work available from everyone involved in the activities (from transportation to coffee shops along the way).
This is inarguably great news for America, but it’s also a movie we’ve seen before, isn’t it?
Fast forward a few years and the likely story will be about bust again, not boom. The car makers will get greedy, seeing all the consumer demand as opportunities to add extras to vehicles so they can charge more for them. Fuel efficiency will fade as a purchase motivator just as the efficiency averages for the most popular vehicles will decline. Then OPEC will get greedy, or there’ll be war in the Middle East, so gas prices will skyrocket. All those auto loans will start looking onerous as the resale value of vehicles plummets again, forcing many people to sell anyway to minimize losses (and flooding the market with more vehicles, thereby reducing prices further). Plants will slow or shut down entirely.
And all those workers will be required to take pay cuts, put on furlough, or fired outright.
Whether events play out exactly as I’ve described doesn’t matter; you have to be a fool not to acknowledge that there’s a cyclical ebb-and-flow to the auto industry, and that it tends to gyrate rather wildly between boom and bust times.
So isn’t it a little weird that nobody is talking about what to do about better managing it?
It’s as if busts and booms were a fact of life or nature, which they’re not. Capitalism tolerates them as imperfections of time and the transparency of information, and the mechanism of the marketplace is intended to correct them. No brand benefits from the boom times enough to happily endure the busts...actually, far from it. Car brands seem to exist at the whim of external forces beyond their understanding or control. What we consumers think about the auto industry is dependent on how we feel about the country and our economy, not what the brands tell us.
This situation is a bit weird considering the automakers spend billions of dollars marketing to us each year. They’re just telling us very little that’s relevant to the Bigger Picture.
While I believe in the awe-inspiring power of marketers, I know that we can’t change the basic rules that drive the global economy. But I do think automakers could fiddle with the way they communicate to the marketplace to help lessen the crazy ups and downs in the business of selling cars. Here are a few thought-starter ideas:
Even if my ideas aren’t the right ones, you’d think we’d be seeing something different coming from the car marketers these days (other than nonsense social media campaigns). If they don’t embrace a rethink of their approach, I suspect they’re doomed to ride the boom until it crashes into the bust. Again.
And again, and again.
This blog reflects the personal opinions of individual contributors and does not represent the views of Futurelab, Futurelab's clients, or the contributors' respective employers or clients.